In 1971 Flight International produced a special edition on Concorde. It said: "The dawn of supersonic commercial flight is upon us. Within the decade Concorde should be claiming international business, saving passengers time and making money for airlines.

"Here we present a review of the prospects for Concorde - we show the sonic boom to be a minor issue.

"Concorde will sell at £24 million. The return on the investment should be 15%.

"In the same year Richard Wiggs, in his book Concorde the Case Against Supersonic Transport, and in national newspapers, made criticism of supersonic flight intellectually respectable. He pointed out that a vast sum of money was irrecoverably spent on an aircraft which:

makes an intolerable damaging sonic bang and unacceptable noise at airports; would be unprofitable to operate; in terms of aircraft capacity and environmental acceptability was already out of date; was in any commercial sense unsaleable.

The history of Concorde bears out this assessment.

Margaret Wiggs

Biggleswade, Bedfordshire, UK

Source: Flight International